Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the web’s best products. If you purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. Our editorial team is independent and only endorses products we believe in.
What we love
The not so good parts
If you’re even remotely plugged into modern parenting, you’ve probably noticed that kids’ audio players are having a moment. These little boxes are essentially podcasts and audiobooks made just for kids, and promise screen-free entertainment, independent play, and maybe even a little peace and quiet. Gone are the days when reading meant sitting down with a physical book.
As a mom of three who doesn’t own an audio player (yet), I found myself wondering: am I missing out? Are audio players actually beneficial or just another hyped-up parenting gadget?To get some clarity, I reached out to Danielle Bouchard, M.A., a literacy education expert, to learn more about the benefits of audio stories for kids. Then, I took a deep dive into the two biggest names in the game – Yoto Player and Toniebox – to see how they compare and which one might actually be worth buying.
Why I’m Considering an Audio Player
As a parent, one of my biggest struggles is getting my kids to self-play or self-entertain. In my ideal world, they’d curl up on the couch with a book, fully immerse in building an epic LEGO city, or quietly play with dolls or figurines in their room. In reality, that rarely (never!) happens. What I’ve realized is that my kids need the right kind of stimulation. That’s where audio stories come in. They provide just the right mix of background noise and stimulation to keep kids engaged while freeing their hands to build, draw, or play on their own.
In the past, when I’ve put on an audio story in the background using Spotify, I’ve noticed my kids are far more likely to stay focused on what they’re doing without constantly calling for me. Even better, audio stories let their imaginations take the lead. Instead of seeing every detail on a screen, they’re creating the characters and scenes in their own heads, which feels like a big win for both creativity and independence. All of this is what’s convinced me that an audio player is exactly what our home needs.
Benefits of Audio Stories
According to Bouchard, listening to audio stories is a powerful way for kids to build early reading skills. “Audio players are a great way to spark, or continue building, a child’s interest in stories,” she explains. “They naturally absorb new vocabulary, strengthen comprehension, and develop a sense of story structure.” I love this because it means my kids are learning even when I’m not hovering over them with a book.
“With the right support, kids can choose what they want to listen to and create routines around engaging with their favorite stories, and that sense of ownership often leads to more curiosity about books in general,” says Bouchard. “One of the most important parts of supporting early literacy is helping children enjoy reading, and audiobooks make stories feel fun and accessible.” And ultimately, that’s what matters most to me – when stories feel enjoyable and accessible, kids are far more likely to develop a genuine love of reading.
Other benefits of audio players include:
- Screen-free entertainment
- Stronger listening skills
- Greater accessibility for reluctant readers or kids with learning differences
- Fostering a love of storytelling
The Drawbacks of Audio Stories
As much as I love the idea of audio stories, they’re not perfect. “Audio stories are wonderful, but they work best alongside (not instead of) reading aloud,” Bouchard says. “Some children may drift in and out of focus without pictures or print to anchor them, and certain stories can feel too fast-paced or overstimulating depending on the child.” That’s why I make it a point to be selective about what we listen to and match stories to my kids’ interests and age. And of course, print books still have a permanent spot in our routine, because nothing beats snuggling up with a book and flipping through the pages together.
Yoto Player vs. Toniebox: Which One Is Better?
I’m putting these two popular audio players head‑to‑head to figure out which one deserves a permanent spot in our home. But before diving into features and specs, here are a few factors I’m thinking about:
- My children's ages and independence levels
- Literacy levels
- Audio options (stories, music, sleep sounds, games, educational content)
- Story options that match their interests
- A library that can grow with them over time
The Yoto Player is a kid-friendly audio device that uses Yoto cards to play stories, music, and more. All you do is pop in a story card, and it starts playing. With over 1,000 card options covering different ages, genres, and themes, there’s something for every child – from The Magic Treehouse series to The Chronicles of Narnia. You can even create your own custom story cards, which is a fun way to personalize your listening experience.
Beyond storytelling, the Yoto Player doubles as a versatile tool for daily routines. It includes an OK-to-wake night light and clock, kid-friendly buttons to skip chapters or adjust volume, Bluetooth connectivity so parents can control it from their phones, sleep sounds, sleep radio, and an alarm. For personal listening, you can plug in headphones or connect to wireless headphones or earbuds.
Specs:
- For ages 3 to 12+
- Bluetooth and WiFi connectivity
- USB-C fast charge
- Wireless charging (dock sold separately)
- Up to 24hrs playback
- 40mm 5W stereo speaker
- 32GB internal memory
- 600+ hours of storage for offline listening
- Ambient night light
- Room temperature thermometer
- Access to the Yoto app
What we love
The not so good parts
The Toniebox 2 is a screen-free audio player that comes in a variety of fun colors and plays content through little figurines called Tonies. Just place a Tonie on top of the box, and it starts telling a story, playing music, or delivering educational content. With hundreds of Tonies available, you can choose by age, genre, or favorite character – think Peppa Pig, Disney classics, and more. You can also create your own “Creative Tonie” to upload personalized stories or messages.
The Toniebox has intuitive controls, so kids can pinch, tap, tilt, or squeeze the “ears” on top to adjust volume, start or stop stories, or switch tracks. It pairs with Bluetooth headphones that can last up to 40 hours, perfect for on-the-go listening. For bedtime, Toniesbox offers sleep-focused Tonies and smart sleep features like a sleep timer with a light that gradually fades sound and glow to help kids drift off peacefully.
Specs
- Ages 1 to 9+
- Choose from 300+ Tonies
- Dynamic Light Ring
- Access to Tonies app
- Bluetooth and Wifi connectivity
- USB-C charging cable
What we love
The not so good parts
Which One I’ll Buy
After comparing both, I don’t think there’s a “right” answer because the better choice really depends on your kids and your lifestyle. For my family, I’m leaning toward the Yoto Player. I can’t see myself using an audio player for kids under three, and I love that Yoto grows well beyond age 12, which makes it feel like a longer-term investment. The huge range of content is another big draw for me and the expansive library that can easily grow alongside my kids and their changing interests. Plus, I personally prefer the cards, which feel easier to store and less bulky than keeping track of multiple figurines.
That said, I completely understand why parents of younger kids love the Toniebox. The figurines, ultra-intuitive controls, and playful design feel like the perfect fit for toddlers and preschoolers. At the end of the day, both are thoughtfully designed, screen-free tools that encourage literacy, imagination, and independent play. And honestly, if an audio player keeps my kids engaged, sparks creativity, and buys me a few uninterrupted minutes to make dinner, well, that already feels like a parenting win.
